top of page

The Law Says Your Letter Arrived the Moment You Posted It

Writer: Feed the Reader
Feed the Reader
3 hours ago
4 min read

On 2 September 1817, a firm of wool dealers wrote to some buyers offering to sell them a quantity of fleeces, and asked for an answer by return of post. Then they addressed the letter wrongly.


It went to the wrong county, and the buyers didn't receive it until the evening of 5 September. They wrote back that same evening, accepting.


The sellers, meanwhile, had worked out when a reply ought to arrive. When nothing came by 7 September, they assumed the buyers weren't interested, and on the 8th they sold the wool to someone else. The buyers' "yes" turned up on the 9th.


So who had bought the wool? The buyers sued, and in June 1818 the Court of King's Bench gave an answer that still sits in contract law textbooks. The deal had been done the moment the acceptance was posted.


The ordinary rule

To see why that's strange, it helps to know the usual position.


A contract, a legally binding agreement, normally forms when one side makes an offer and the other accepts it. The person who makes the offer is called the offeror, and the general idea is that the offeror has to actually learn of the acceptance. Nodding silently in another room doesn't count. The "yes" has to reach the other side.


By that logic, the wool dealers were in the clear. They hadn't heard "yes" when they sold the wool, so surely they were still free to sell it.


The puzzle the court saw

The court didn't accept that, and its reasoning is the fun part.


If the sellers weren't bound until they received the buyers' answer, the judges reasoned, then the buyers shouldn't be bound until they knew the sellers had received it. And the sellers wouldn't be bound until they knew the buyers knew, and so on. Every letter would need another letter confirming it had arrived. The court said this could go on ad infinitum, which is Latin for forever.


Under that rule, nobody could ever finish a deal by post. And in 1818, the post was how a great deal of business got done.


The fix

So the court cut the loop. It treated the sellers as making their offer afresh at every moment the letter was travelling. When the buyers put their acceptance in the post, offer and acceptance met, and the deal was complete.


It also mattered that the delay was the sellers' own fault. They had misaddressed the letter, so they could hardly complain that the reply came late.


Later courts built on the idea, and by the end of the nineteenth century it was settled in English law that, where it's reasonable to accept by post, acceptance takes effect when the letter is posted. Henthorn v Fraser, decided in 1892, is one of the cases usually cited for tidying up that timing.


In effect, the postbox became the meeting point. The moment the envelope drops through the slot, the deal is done.


A letter that never arrives

Follow that logic to the end and you get something odd. If the contract forms when the letter goes into the post, it doesn't much matter whether the letter ever arrives.


English courts accepted that too. In an 1879 case, Household Fire Insurance v Grant, an acceptance that was posted but never reached the other side was still treated as having made a contract.


That sounds unfair until you ask who chose the post. Someone who makes an offer by letter has invited a reply by letter, with all the delays and mishaps that come with it, so the rule puts that risk on them. They can also avoid it altogether by making clear in the offer that they need to actually receive the acceptance.


Why it doesn't simply cover your phone

The postal rule was built around one feature of the post: delay. There's a gap of days between a letter being written and being read, and the rule exists to say where in that gap the deal falls.


When communication is instant, there's no gap to fill. In a 1955 case called Entores, an English court held that acceptances sent by telex, an early instant-messaging machine used by businesses, take effect when they're received, not when they're sent, because both sides are effectively in conversation. In 1983, in Brinkibon v Stahag Stahl, the House of Lords endorsed that approach for telex, while stressing it wasn't a universal rule.


Email is trickier. It feels instant, but messages can sit on servers, land in spam folders or go unread for hours. Lawyers and legal scholars have long debated how, or whether, the old rule should apply, and the answer can differ from one country to another.


History, not advice

A few caveats are worth keeping in view. The postal rule is a default: it applies only when posting is a reasonable way to accept, and the person making an offer can rule it out. It differs between legal systems. English courts have themselves described it as a rule of convenience or commercial expediency rather than strict logic, and some scholars argue the line it draws was always somewhat arbitrary.


This article is about the history of an idea in contract law, not a guide to any real agreement. How the rules apply to an actual contract depends on where you are and what was agreed, and that's a question for a lawyer.


The postbox, again

Go back to that misaddressed letter about fleeces. The court faced a genuine logical trap: insist on receipt, and every confirmation needs its own confirmation, forever. Its way out was a small legal fiction, the pretence that the deal happens at the postbox.


It's a strange rule. It's also a reminder that the law sometimes has to pick a moment and stick to it, because otherwise nobody would ever know when a "yes" really counts.


Sources

  1. BAILII, Adams & Ors v Lindsell & Ors [1818] EWHC KB J59 (5 June 1818). https://mansfield.bailii.org/ew/cases/EWHC/KB/1818/J59.html (accessed 31 Oct 2026)

  2. Wikipedia, "Adams v Lindsell". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adams_v_Lindsell (accessed 31 Oct 2026)

  3. N. W. Sage, "The significance of Adams v Lindsell", Journal of Contract Law 36(2) (2020), via LSE Research Online. https://researchonline.lse.ac.uk/id/eprint/101571/1/Significance_of_Adams_v_Lindsell.pdf (accessed 31 Oct 2026)

  4. Society for Computers and Law, "E-mail and the Postal Rule". https://www.scl.org/393-e-mail-and-the-postal-rule/ (accessed 31 Oct 2026)

  5. Will Malcomson, "Adams v Lindsell" (case summary). https://www.willmalcomson.com/articles/adams-v-lindsell (accessed 31 Oct 2026)

  6. Wikipedia, "Household Fire and Carriage Accident Insurance Co Ltd v Grant". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_Fire_and_Carriage_Accident_Insurance_Co_Ltd_v_Grant (accessed 31 Oct 2026)

  7. Wikipedia, "Brinkibon Ltd v Stahag Stahl und Stahlwarenhandelsgesellschaft mbH". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brinkibon_Ltd_v_Stahag_Stahl_und_Stahlwarenhandelsgesellschaft_mbH (accessed 31 Oct 2026)

Featured

Get Feed the Reader's latest articles straight to your inbox. Sign up for our weekly newsletter.

© 2026 Feed the Reader.

bottom of page