The "38 Witnesses" Story Is Not the Whole Story of Helping

If you've ever read an introductory psychology textbook, there's a good chance you've met this story.
In 1964, a young woman named Kitty Genovese was murdered in New York. According to the version that became famous, 38 of her neighbours saw or heard the attack, and not one of them did anything to help.
It's a story that has been told and retold as a lesson about human nature. Put enough people in one place, it seems to say, and everyone will assume someone else will act. So nobody does.
It's a powerful story. But it turns out it isn't an accurate one.
Checking the foundation
In 2007, psychologists Rachel Manning, Mark Levine and Alan Collins took a close look at the evidence behind the "38 witnesses" in a paper in the journal American Psychologist. They called it a parable.
According to a summary of their work by the British Psychological Society, the prosecutor in the case later said that "we only found about half a dozen [witnesses] that saw what was going on, that we could use". According to the 2007 analysis, none of the three eyewitnesses who testified at the trial reported seeing the stabbing itself. The attacker abandoned his first attempt after a witness shouted at him. And a man who had been a 15-year-old witness at the time later said in a sworn statement that his father had phoned the police.
That's a very different picture from 38 people watching and doing nothing.
Two different questions
It's worth separating two things here, because they easily get tangled.
One question is whether the famous story is true. The other is whether the bystander effect is real. The bystander effect is the idea, tested in experiments, that each individual person can be less likely to help when other people are around.
The authors of the 2007 paper didn't dispute the bystander effect. Their point was different. They argued that the Genovese story had become a kind of urban myth, and that it had steered research away from asking how groups of people might actually help those in need.
What the cameras saw
So how often do people help in real life? That's surprisingly hard to study. Real emergencies are unpredictable, and researchers can't ethically create them.
A team led by Richard Philpot, of Lancaster University and the University of Copenhagen, found another way. They studied CCTV footage of 219 real arguments and assaults in public places, in three cities: Amsterdam in the Netherlands, Lancaster in the UK and Cape Town in South Africa. The results were first published online in 2019.
What they found was striking. In 91% of the incidents, at least one bystander intervened. And typically, it wasn't just one person but several.
Reading the number carefully
That 91% figure needs a little care, though. It doesn't mean that 91% of the people who saw an incident stepped in. It means that in 91% of incidents, someone did.
That distinction turns out to be the key to the whole puzzle. The researchers also found that a victim was more likely to receive help when more bystanders were present.
How does that square with the bystander effect? Philpot's explanation is neat. A crowd may make each individual person a little less likely to help. But it also, as he put it, "provides a larger pool from which help-givers may be sourced". More people means more chances that somebody acts.
Both things can be true at once. Each person can be a bit less likely to help, and yet the crowd as a whole is more likely to produce a helper.
What this doesn't show
It's important not to swing too far the other way. These were public arguments and assaults in three cities, not every kind of emergency, everywhere. The footage shows what happened, not why each person acted as they did. And none of this disproves the bystander effect seen in experiments.
The power of a story
What this really shows is how much a single, memorable story can shape the questions we think to ask. Manning and her colleagues argue that, for decades, the "38 witnesses" steered researchers towards asking why people fail to help. The CCTV study asked a different question: what actually happens when people do?
And the answer, in these cities at least, was that most of the time, somebody stepped in.
Sources
R. Manning, M. Levine and A. Collins, "The Kitty Genovese murder and the social psychology of helping: The parable of the 38 witnesses", American Psychologist 62(6), 555–562 (2007). https://eprints.lancs.ac.uk/id/eprint/3591/ (accessed 7 Nov 2026)
C. Jarrett, "The truth behind the story of Kitty Genovese and the bystander effect", BPS Research Digest (23 Oct 2007). https://www.bps.org.uk/research-digest/truth-behind-story-kitty-genovese-and-bystander-effect (accessed 7 Nov 2026)
R. Philpot et al., "Would I be helped? Cross-national CCTV footage shows that intervention is the norm in public conflicts", American Psychologist 75(1), 66–75 (online 2019; issue 2020). https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000469 (accessed 7 Nov 2026)
Lancaster University, "Bystanders will intervene to help victims of aggressive public disputes" (26 Jun 2019). https://www.lancaster.ac.uk/news/bystanders-will-intervene-to-help-victims-of-aggressive-public-disputes (accessed 7 Nov 2026)









