Most of a Proton's Mass Is Not the Sum of Its Quarks

Here's a simple bit of shopping-list arithmetic. A proton, one of the particles at the heart of every atom, is built around three smaller particles called quarks: two "up" quarks and one "down" quark. Physicists call these its valence quarks. A proton also contains gluons and a constant fizz of short-lived quark–antiquark pairs, but let's start simple.
So if you want to know what a proton weighs, surely you just look up the masses of those three quarks and add them together?
It's a perfectly reasonable thing to try. And it gives you a hopelessly wrong answer.
The missing mass
The quarks' own rest masses are far too small. Added up, they're nowhere near enough to account for the proton. In fact, physicists can say something even more striking. If you could somehow set the masses of the up, down and strange quarks to zero, the proton would barely notice. As the physicist André Walker-Loud put it, writing in the journal Physics, "the proton would still have more than 90% of its experimental mass".
So where does the rest come from?
What the Higgs does, and doesn't, do
You may have heard that particles get their mass from the Higgs. That's true for the quarks themselves: they get their masses through what's called the Higgs mechanism.
But that only covers the quarks' own mass. And since the quarks' own mass is a small part of the proton's, the Higgs isn't the main explanation for why protons weigh what they do. It matters. It just isn't the whole story.
A very busy interior
The answer lies in the strong force, the force that holds quarks together.
The strong force is carried by particles called gluons. Inside a proton, quarks and gluons are constantly moving and interacting, and they're held tightly together. In fact, they're confined: you never find a quark wandering around on its own.
All of that motion and interaction carries energy. And thanks to Einstein, we know that energy and mass are two sides of the same coin. The energy of a system counts towards its mass.
So most of a proton's mass comes, in Walker-Loud's words, "purely from the motion and confinement of quarks and gluons".
A word of caution. It's tempting to picture this as a little bag of glowing energy trapped inside the proton. That's not quite right either. The mass belongs to the whole interacting system, the quarks, the gluons and the field that binds them, not to a separate substance stored inside.
How do you check something like that?
You can't open up a proton and look. So physicists use a technique called lattice QCD. QCD stands for quantum chromodynamics, the theory of the strong force.
The method replaces smooth space and time with a grid, a lattice. As Walker-Loud describes it, it "places quarks on the sites of a lattice and gluons on the links between them". Then powerful computers work out how the whole thing behaves. It's not a photograph of the proton's ingredients. It's a numerical calculation of the theory, with uncertainties attached.
In 2018, a team led by Yi-Bo Yang used this approach to break the proton's mass down into four contributions. Some relate to the quarks, some to the gluons, and together they account for the proton's mass.
Why the percentages are tricky
You'll sometimes see neat percentages quoted for how much of the proton's mass each piece contributes. Be a little wary of these.
How you split the mass up depends on exactly how you define each piece, and physicists have to choose a specific scheme to do it. Different questions give different-looking numbers. For example, "what do the three quark masses add up to?" and "how much of the proton's mass is tied to quark mass in a full calculation?" sound similar but aren't the same question at all.
What doesn't change is the headline. Most of the proton's mass is not the mass of its quarks.
Back to the ordinary world
Protons, together with neutrons, make up the nuclei of atoms. And nuclei carry almost all the mass of ordinary matter. Neutrons are made of quarks and gluons too, and the same broad story applies to them.
So the next time you pick something up, it's worth appreciating what you're feeling. Most of that heft doesn't come from the rest masses of the smallest particles inside it. It comes from the restless motion and confinement of quarks and gluons inside each proton and neutron.
Sources
A. Walker-Loud, "Dissecting the Mass of the Proton", Physics 11, 118 (19 Nov 2018). https://physics.aps.org/articles/v11/118 (accessed 7 Nov 2026)
Y.-B. Yang et al., "Proton Mass Decomposition from the QCD Energy Momentum Tensor", Physical Review Letters 121, 212001 (19 Nov 2018). https://journals.aps.org/prl/abstract/10.1103/PhysRevLett.121.212001 (accessed 7 Nov 2026)









